The Myth of “We’re Not Ready”

  • We rely on just a few big givers.
  • People are tired; it’s always the same few carrying the load.
  • The economy feels uncertain.
  • We need more bids, more estimates, more clarity before we even think about moving forward.
  • We’re a small church — surely we couldn’t do something like this.

I don’t often hear a church say directly, “We’re not ready.” What I hear instead are thoughtful concerns like the ones above.

These comments aren’t careless. In fact, the leaders who make them are paying attention. They are trying to be prudent. They are trying to protect their congregation from overreaching or making a misstep. Because leaders know that a poorly timed effort can have long-lasting consequences.

But when I listen carefully, I sometimes hear something underneath all of that: a quiet assumption that we are waiting for conditions to improve before we take the next step.

And that’s where a line from Ecclesiastes has been lingering in my mind:

Whoever watches the wind will not plant;
whoever looks at the clouds will not reap.
(11:4)

That verse doesn’t feel harsh. It feels honest. A farmer pays attention to the weather. Wind and clouds matter. Conditions matter. But Ecclesiastes names something deeply human. If watching the wind becomes the primary activity, planting never happens. And when nothing is planted, nothing grows.

Church leaders are especially attentive to the forecast. We track attendance patterns and giving trends. We notice demographic shifts. We pay attention to the mood of the congregation. We study bids and estimates and spreadsheets. None of that is foolish. Discernment requires awareness.

But there is always wind, and there are always clouds.

If it’s not economic uncertainty, it’s leadership fatigue. If it’s not fatigue, it’s a capital repair that feels too large. If it’s not a repair, it’s concern about relying too heavily on a handful of generous members. Ideal conditions rarely arrive all at once. And so the list of reasonable concerns can quietly extend from one season to the next.

A few verses later, Ecclesiastes reminds us:

As you do not know the way the spirit comes to
the bones in the womb of a woman with child,
so you do not know the work of God who makes everything.
(11:5)

That is not an argument against planning. It is a reminder that certainty is never guaranteed. We do not know in advance which effort will flourish. We do not control outcomes.

And then comes the steady encouragement:

Sow your seed in the morning,
and at evening do not let your hands be idle;
for you do not know which will prosper, this or that.
(11:6)

Over the years, we’ve had the privilege of walking alongside churches in very different contexts. Some are larger and suburban. Some are small and rural. Some have strong reserves; others feel stretched. Some have long-term pastors; others have interims.

The ones who eventually move forward are rarely in perfect circumstances. What they tend to share is clarity — a shared understanding of their mission and a willingness to engage it honestly.

To me, that signals readiness.

Readiness is not the absence of structural challenges. It is not flawless unity or complete financial certainty. It is not waiting until every bid is finalized or every variable is controlled. Readiness is leadership alignment. It is clarity about why you exist. It is the courage to begin conversations that may feel uncomfortable but are necessary.

Sometimes the concerns churches name are real work that needs to be done. If you rely on a few large givers, that may be an invitation to broaden engagement. If people are tired, that may be a sign that leadership needs to be shared more intentionally. If information is incomplete, that may be a reason to begin gathering it rather than postponing indefinitely.

What can happen, though, is that caution slowly becomes the new normal. Deferred maintenance becomes accepted. Big questions are delayed year after year. Energy shifts from vision to management. Nothing collapses dramatically. But very little is planted.

The farmer who never plants in the spring simply has nothing to harvest in the fall. That feels like the deeper wisdom Ecclesiastes is offering. Watching the wind is understandable. But watching alone does not produce fruit.

So perhaps the better question for many churches is not, “Are we ready?” but rather, “What seed could we plant in this season?”

Planting might mean:

  • beginning a structured conversation about your long-term sustainability
  • commissioning a study to understand your facilities more clearly
  • naming the gap between your mission and your current capacity with honesty.

It does not necessarily mean launching something big tomorrow. It simply means moving from observation to action.

In early March, the ground in much of the country is still cold. The skies remain unpredictable. If you were waiting for a perfectly calm forecast, you might never begin. And yet planting season comes every year, not because the wind or clouds disappear, but because growth requires someone to put a seed in the soil.

Ecclesiastes offers a steady reminder: whoever watches the wind will not plant. There will always be reasons to wait. The question is whether, even amid uncertainty, we are willing to begin.

 

    Comments are closed.